I agree with salmo. Guiding on the Quinault builds a constituency for sportfishing there, and that is a better use of the resource. Morally wrong? Isn't guiding also a commercial use of that natural resource? Tell me about morality. The Quinaults have been there for maybe 9,000 years (note that there is still native stock) and you're telling them how to manage their river? And about hatchery fish, are y'all against planting hatchery fish in the Bog/Cal and what about the Snyder Creek program? The Quinaults do use native stock I believe. Ripping the tribe and boycotting sportfishing there is not a great approach for encouraging higher escapement goals.