I disagree. There IS a distinct difference in the two......mainly that ONE can be done selctively with very low mortality. I know Bob's stance on keeping wild fish, so it is kind of insulting to him, and many other guides, to group them in the same category as commercial netters.

I still maintain that less netting would take place if alternative income.....like income from guiding, was available. The more tribal guides there are, the more fish they are going to want in the river to hook their clients up with. At least that's the way I would hope it would work.