A well run "Broodstock" program would get my vote. We'd still have hatchery fish for the taking and they would be of much higher quality. If they were of "nate" origin the run timing wouldn't be so critical. In order to make a program work the volunteers would have to be committed and walk the talk, and the state and tribal fisheries managers would have to trust the effort.
_________________________
It's wonderful to be good. But it's better if you're lucky and good!