More like the Keith vs. John battle...

Neither of them outfish one or the other.

They work equally well in the right given situation.

Herzog would say to hell with your bait and goofy looking weighted flies and preach hardware!

If you've got the deaddrift presentation down for jigs, but you can't present a cluster of eggs worth beans, then you better stick to your jigs and vise versa.

Just my .02

Harbor-Hog