It looks to me like the guide has it under control,looks like he is poised to take fish and release him. i understand they should not have taken him out of the water but i think we all have done things we look back on and say wtf was i thinking. who are we to judge everyone's actions. i also want to add i have a 8 year old boy who would bonk everything if i let him. seen many of tears on his face after letting some of his prize fish go..give him a break.