Smalma,
In re-reading my response to your comments on #5, my defense of that position is pretty weak. Lead Bouncer is right on the money in that CCA should not be held responsible for statements by members that are hasty or ill informed.
I personally believe that selective harvest impacts the success of matching actual catch to projected returns under the present system. I can see how that can be discounted as hair splitting, and I apologize. In future, I'll let the better informed and politically adept debate policy.