1) If the object is not to kill wild fish, then they are each a problem in and of themselves.

There was a discussion on here several years back where the take produced by catch and release enabled the tribes to net their share of steelhead on the OP.

2) If that is true, then CnR not only kills wild fish but then enables others to kill wild fish also.

You would think that these organizations that want to protect wild fish would not like that at all.