Oops on the acronym snafu. I was referring yo the WFC. While I agree that most comparisons between the Umpqua and any Washington stream are misguided, I stand by my assertion that the biggest threat hatchery fish pose to wild fish in any stream is the overharvest of wild fish in fisheries targeting the hatchery fish. The same open ocean fisheries affect every population, regardless of any subsequent fisheries that occur in-river. Gillnetting is just one more strike against already overfished populations.