The habitat is in terrible condition is the problem. If you were to stop all fishing on the West Coast these wild Chinook still could not recover. I recieved this from Curt Kraemer this morning on the sediment in the river.
"Based on this estimate, landslide material accounted for about 30 percent of the total suspended sediment load in the lower Stillaguamish River between March 2014 and September 2015."
Sediment information came from a USGS study. "Geomorphic Response of the North Fork Stillaguamish River to the State Route 30 landslide near Oso, Washington", a 2017 report
https://pubs.usgs.gov/sir/2017/5055/sir20175055.pdfThe relevant find comes from the 4 th paragraph in the Stanwood section on Page 44.
So 70% of the sediment is from other sources other than the Oso Landslide. The available habitat/river capacity for wild chinook is about 930. Curt ran the numbers. WDFW modelers back it up with 900-1000 fish. Page 167 of the plan states that Chinook recovery is highly unlikely in its current form.
I dont think all of the tribes were involved with the Stilly. Each had to deal with its own rivers/UandA. I think this is more of a Stilly issue than all tribal issue. I have feed back that quite a few tribes are not liking this either. Most think that it is a green light for them but its not. It the impacts are to go over the new 8% they might not fish either.
So this really is not a tribal issue except for the Stilly Tribe. I think they made a stand for very little-to no fishing for last 25 years. They want their river fixed or something to happen to help fix it. I guess they made their point and were heard.
We are working on a solution to the problem. I cannot say what that is right now but am feeling better about our outcome. It has been a 4+ week exploration for us. The best thing anyone can do is to email a letter to the Commission and let them know your thoughts.
At the last meeting with WDFW over this, they told us they had a meeting scheduled with the commission and the commission was going to direct them on what was to be done.
So do your part right now and email a letter to the commission telling them that you want this Puget Sound Chinook Harvest Management Plan either altered or rescinded, but cannot live with it in its current state, if you agree. This helps the newer non fish commissioners understand from our perspective how we feel and want to see happen.
commission@dfw.wa.gov,
PSA is in the process of putting together a letter to the commission behalf of our chapters and the recreationals. We will be sending out an Voter Voice announcement for others too.