Fish ID

Posted by: eyeFISH

Fish ID - 03/12/20 09:35 PM

Whaddaya think....

Posted by: On The Swing

Re: Fish ID - 03/12/20 09:38 PM

Oh lord..just like coronovirus it's here now too.


That's a coho btw
Posted by: Anonymous

Re: Fish ID - 03/12/20 10:08 PM

It's a salmon.
Posted by: eyeFISH

Re: Fish ID - 03/12/20 10:45 PM

I wanna know how bushbear and Tug3 would enforce this?
Posted by: Todd

Re: Fish ID - 03/13/20 06:08 AM

Outside of the spots everything about it looks like a sockeye...

Fish on...

Todd
Posted by: snit

Re: Fish ID - 03/13/20 06:11 AM

Originally Posted By: Todd
Outside of the spots everything about it looks like a sockeye...

Fish on...

Todd


That was my first thought, besides that it looks yummy too!
Posted by: SpoonFed

Re: Fish ID - 03/13/20 06:18 AM

Originally Posted By: Todd
Outside of the spots everything about it looks like a sockeye...

Fish on...

Todd


+1
Posted by: 5 * General Evo

Re: Fish ID - 03/13/20 06:19 AM

lets see the tail...
Posted by: RUNnGUN

Re: Fish ID - 03/13/20 07:37 AM

Sockho.
Posted by: Anonymous

Re: Fish ID - 03/13/20 08:07 AM

Cockeye?
Posted by: Jason Beezuz

Re: Fish ID - 03/13/20 08:24 AM

Steelhead with Covid-19 and complications of viral pneumonia.


JK, its a sockeye IMO.
Posted by: SpoonFed

Re: Fish ID - 03/13/20 08:27 AM

Originally Posted By: AcidAngler
Cockeye?


Lol..
Posted by: On The Swing

Re: Fish ID - 03/13/20 08:47 AM

In case anyone is wondering the meat color was ORANGE on this fish, not red
Posted by: cohoangler

Re: Fish ID - 03/13/20 09:27 AM

Sockeye. Oncorhynchus nerka.

The lack of spots on the lower lobe of the caudal fin is the key.
Posted by: bushbear

Re: Fish ID - 03/13/20 09:47 AM

If the season is open and possession is permitted and there is a license to cover the possession, l don’t see any problems.

Not a Colorado river that I recognize. If illegal, and brought back into Colorado, there would be a number of options available for enforcement to consider.
Posted by: Jaydee

Re: Fish ID - 03/13/20 12:27 PM

Spots, eye size, and scale size say coho.
Posted by: The Moderator

Re: Fish ID - 03/13/20 12:49 PM

The infamous CHINARK!!!!!!!
Posted by: NickD90

Re: Fish ID - 03/13/20 01:51 PM

Yes - where was it caught?

Colorado river Bushbear? I'm confused here.

Colorado does have nice Kokanee fishing for some real brutes (2 - 5 pounders - they eat mysis shrimp all day). Some of them do migrate from reservoir to reservoir through connecting rivers (eg. Elevenmile to Spinney), but those rivers are tiny and short (and not the Colorado).

The only other area on the Colorado River I can think of is Glen Canyon in Utah, but I don't know anything about that....
Posted by: SpoonFed

Re: Fish ID - 03/13/20 02:03 PM

It's a unique specimen..

It has the small scales and the body of a sock but it's got spots on its back.

Doesn't look like it has many teeth either.

Crazy catch.
Posted by: Salmo g.

Re: Fish ID - 03/13/20 02:42 PM

Humpeye?

Sockeye is best I can tell from that photo.
Posted by: kalamageo

Re: Fish ID - 03/13/20 03:26 PM

I'm going with coho. Too many spots and looking toothy. The white gum line is sticking out to me also .

Just to be safe, I'm sticking it in a bag and hiding it under the floor.......

My text book was of little use. Without the fish in hand and ability to see tail and count fin rays and gill arches, couldn't key it properly.

Always "enjoyed" walking into class at FRI on Montlake, smelling THAT SMELL and going into class and finding dozens of plates with "specimens" to key...........
Posted by: eddie

Re: Fish ID - 03/13/20 03:46 PM

I initially thought sockeye as well but the spots and eye size say coho. Maybe a hybrid? Where was it caught?
Posted by: bushbear

Re: Fish ID - 03/13/20 06:26 PM

I should have said that it isn’t a river in Colorado that I recognize. Wasn’t trying to say it was the Colorado River.

Yes, there are some dandy Kokanee in Colorado. I think Eleven Mile reservoir is the location of the state record and I think it is over 6 lbs, but I have been gone for 20 years. Blue Mesa has Kokanee, as does Granby and Green Mountain. CDOW/CPW used to give away limits of Kokanee from their spawning operations.
Posted by: 4Salt

Re: Fish ID - 03/13/20 07:57 PM

I've seen big Kokanee develop small spots when entering into spawning phase.

My guess: Kokanee / Sockeye.
Posted by: Anonymous

Re: Fish ID - 03/13/20 08:32 PM

I agree with the sockeye guess, looks like a Quinault fish I hooked a few years ago. Although that was in summer.
Posted by: NickD90

Re: Fish ID - 03/13/20 08:36 PM

Originally Posted By: bushbear
I should have said that it isn’t a river in Colorado that I recognize. Wasn’t trying to say it was the Colorado River.

Yes, there are some dandy Kokanee in Colorado. I think Eleven Mile reservoir is the location of the state record and I think it is over 6 lbs, but I have been gone for 20 years. Blue Mesa has Kokanee, as does Granby and Green Mountain. CDOW/CPW used to give away limits of Kokanee from their spawning operations.


Gotcha. Big koks are still there. The best in the world however is Flaming Gorge. Like consistent 4 - 6 pound koks. I think Herzog did a special on it a few years back if I remember correctly. I've never fished it for Koks, just monster browns and rainbows.
Posted by: bushbear

Re: Fish ID - 03/13/20 09:42 PM

Those Kokanee grow some big lake trout in those reservoirs.
Posted by: NickD90

Re: Fish ID - 03/14/20 07:29 AM

Originally Posted By: bushbear
Those Kokanee grow some big lake trout in those reservoirs.


Yes sir. We used to ice fish for big Lakers all the time - a couple 25 - 30 pounders have been brought to hand. I even have special ice rods to handle those bigger fish. Tip a 1/2 or 3/4 oz. Pearl Glow Tube Grub with a chunk of Sucker meat and drop down. Easy pickins'.

Back to the fish in question....it's gotta be a Cockeye or something like that IMO.
Posted by: Bobber Down

Re: Fish ID - 03/17/20 05:35 PM

Sharp teeth Coho

Soft teeth Sockeye

That being said looks like a typical green headed sockeye.

BD