I have a pair and they work great if you don't have to handle a bait caster or mend your line.
They will keep your hands dry but I like having my index and thumb tips free. Thats the only fault I have. I guess I will remove the tips and see if that helps. Just hate to have to cut up a pair of glove that are perfect for other stuff but not for fishing.
And they are a little spendy at $30+ per pair. My .02