Can steelhead see pink?

Posted by: floatandjig

Can steelhead see pink? - 01/01/04 08:19 PM

I have read articles in magazines about studies done on the way steelhead see colors. I keep hearing that steelhead can't see pink, but I wonder how that is possible since it is one of the best colors to sucker them with. If they can't see pink, then what does the color pink look like to them? I have also heard rumors that fish can't feel pain either. Is there any truth to this. If you stuck a hook in the lip of any other living creature on earth, I'm sure that they would feel pain. So why doesn't a fish? If they can't feel pain, then how do you explain why a steelhead will sometimes jump instantly after being hooked? I don't think it is because the hook in their lip feels good.
Posted by: silver hilton

Re: Can steelhead see pink? - 01/01/04 09:13 PM

Why would they not be able to see pink? I have never heard that. While I have not seen studies about salmonids, there are well documented studies on largemouth bass that show that they have much finer color resolution than humans.

Pink is just white with a tinge of blood to it. That would be evolutionarily useful for fish to be able to discern. So I'm betting they can see it just fine. They see my pink jigs pretty well, at least.
Posted by: cowlitzfisherman

Re: Can steelhead see pink? - 01/01/04 09:13 PM

The color "pink", in a steelhead eyes may not be the same color that you or I see as the color "pink" as. It may just be a shade of gray, or some other color that they recognize as a food source or it could just be a color that really pisses them off.

Remember, a steelheads brain is only the size of a "pee", so the amount of pain that they may feel is most likely very limited. Why do you jump sometimes when someone makes a noise or grabs you from behind when you are not ready for it? You don't feel any "pain", but you still "jump" don't you? laugh

If pain was a big factor, why would they (steelhead and salmon) let bears, or seals grab them and bite them and yet they just keep on going until they get to wherever their headed?

I don't believe that cold blooded creatures have the same nervous system as a warm blooded creature does, and that may also have an additional effect on how much pain they can feel.

Cowlitzfisherman
Posted by: havnfun

Re: Can steelhead see pink? - 01/01/04 10:12 PM

earlier this last year there was a post dated on 4/30 that had links to several articles about fish and pain.
Posted by: Jaydee

Re: Can steelhead see pink? - 01/01/04 11:52 PM

Just to add, since there's these topics about color, and a fish's sight. (chartruse/pink)
I have read a number of articles about color appearence under water and fishes eyesight as well.
I've been more so concerned myself with the contrast any certain color gives than the actual color of my offering itself.
An example would be that I've used black in low light and or reduced water vis and it's produced, not just with steelies but with all sorts of species.
Another examlpe would be a predatory fish looking up the lit sky of dawn and seing a black silhouette skitter by, and boom.
Even though whatever is skittering is blue, green, purple, red, or any thing that shows as contrasting with the back ground, is still gonna apear as black, atleast as I'd imagine it.
I totally agree that pink is a very productive for steel, as it can be for coho in the salt and even offshore species in Hawaii. I think it's very possible that the contast that pink gives off in certain situations can trigger fish to strike it, not necessarily because they can see, or like pink.
In a river situation I could believe this is similarly relavent in certain ways, especially since steelhead, bite mostly out of reaction as its target is drifting on by, and seldomly examine what they pick up before they strike.
Maybe, this might shed some light on the subject. (No pun intended)
Good question?
Good Fishing.