My dad fished Goodman Creek allot in the 60's and early 70's before they started planting hatchery fish, the fishing was good from thanksgiving till Feb, once hatchery fish got planted the people started showing up and the wild fish were cleaned out accept for the later segment of the run. The damage was done.

I have been to Goodman since they stopped planting it, no fish at all now until mid January, the early wild fish did not return and no hatchery fish to catch either. It is now a dead zone between the coho and late wild steelhead. My point is the wild fish cannot recover once the stock is gone, you just have a river with no fish if you don't supplement.