Maybe CM and Salmo can comment on this. I am going to talk about winter steelhead on the Chehalis system. The state has closed winter steelhead fishing on this system this winter to protect the native steelhead. I live in the South Sound and used to fish the Puyallup and Nisqually for steelhead back in the day. I think the Puyallup has been close for wild steelhead retention about 40 years ago and the Nisqually since the early 90's. Now, both rivers are comletely closedfor steelhead. The wild steelhead runs have improved a little on some of the years on those rivers but never to the numbers to ever allow fishing again. Even CnR fishing. The wild runs will never come back. Getting back to the Chehalis and tribs, I am thinking that that system is following the same path as the Puy and Nis. No winter steelhead fishing again on that system as long as the state is concerned with recovery of wild steelhead. Thoughts?
There's not a lot I can add after reading C'man's and Smalma's posts. Generally, yes, the Chehalis (and OP) steelhead runs are following down the same path as the severely depressed Puyallup and Nisqually populations. I think it isn't for exactly the same reasons however. The OP rivers have the most intact freshwater habitat in the state, so it's fairly logical that those populations are the last to collapse. I think the Chehalis basin is kind of in between the OP and Puget Sound (PS) rivers in terms of freshwater habitat quality. The biggest difference affecting steelhead runs that I can see is that PS river populations have further to travel in estuarine-like waters before reaching the open ocean.
Smolt tagging studies over the last decade illustrate that heavy predation near the river mouths and in PS by marine mammals and some birds is severely limiting the proportion of the steelhead smolt population that makes it to the open ocean. Some of that same kind of predation affects OP and Chehalis steelhead too, but not nearly to as great an extent. We can see in PS populations that the further the distance from the river mouth to the open ocean, the higher the smolt mortality, with the Nisqually River, as the southern-most PS tributary, being the most severely affected.
The recent devastation to OP and Chehalis basin steelhead runs appears related to declining productivity in near-shore ocean waters - like the poor upwelling event that was documented just a few years ago - and more open ocean declines like the large "warm patch" in the central north Pacific (which happens to be the area most of our steelhead populations migrate to), and the potential impact of over-grazing of the north Pacific by massive numbers of Alaskan and Japanese hatchery chum and pink salmon releases, which also migrate to and forage in that central north Pacific zone. The apparent declining productivity there sure seems like it could be a final chapter in a doomsday scenario for PNW steelhead.