Seems way to complicated. These bills always have flaws. Why would you want to clip Pinks, Chum, or Sockeye? Trout planted in lakes? Those are fish I could care less to harvest, and I bet I'm in the majority. Only harvest them when numbers allow. Otherwise C&R only. Manditory clip all hatchery Coho, Chinook and Steelhead. Those are the most targeted and where the demand is. How will the tribes be forced to mark the fish they plant? They resist now, and consider a fish is a fish, wild or hatchery.