I shop at Northman's in Port Orchard for as much as I can based on what they have, which is pretty good for the saltwater and freshwater steelhead and salmon angler.
They are my local shop and I want to support them and keep them around. If they don't have what I need then I keep a list for the next time I am near Sportco. I like supporting them too. I don't buy too much online, but I have bought things from Good Day Fishing for their downrigger fishing terminal gear, good stuff.

For very basic tackle needs, Bi-mart is an underappreciated shop. You won't find a big selection of the latest lure everyone is buying stock in but for hooks, scents, line, some lures (they have a really good selection of spoons, spinfish, etc.) and even some decent reels, don't overlook Bi-mart.