Hi Bob,
Just visited both chat rooms. I like the one that Jen from ifish is using. Have chatted with them on the old one she had and on the new one. Cool thing with the new one is that you can make it full screen. I just like the look of it compared to the second one that you listed. Glad to see you starting one, the Wednesday night chat sessions are a lot of fun. Two weeks ago there must have been 30 people chattin', the screen was moving so fast you could hardly keep up. Even had Tony Floor from WDFW and Clancy Holt on for a while.
Good luck and tight lines, Jeff