Damn, I hadnt intended to log in today, but I just couldnt resist getting my 2 cents worth into this.
First of all, the dam is not the only problem source in the Skok Valley. Logging practices are also to blame. I dont want to defend TCL, but I dont really think they are the sole cause of the problem. I've no idea of how much action has been brought against the timber industry there, by the tribe, but I suspect it hasnt been much. Hmm.. Tribe like logging???
After conversation with others who are more knowledgable than I am, though, I believe the Tribe's position is mostly about the $$ Ca$h. Even though some of them would prefer to see the fish restored, they'll fish anything to extinction, so long as it supports their legal position to litigate about the dam. Paying them off sounds like a great idea until you consider the legal precedences it would establish.
And from what I've heard, they dont want to assume ownership and operation of the power plant, as it is probably too labor-intensive. i.e., theyd have to WORK at it.
The river has lots of good looking spawning habitat, but it will probably never be stocked or restored in any way until the lawsuits about the dam go away. Who in their right mind would do anything to enhance or restore the runs while the tribe would purposely decimate their effort to support their court actions??
TCL seems to have a history of not being very fish-conscious, (look at their actions on the Cowlitz reported in another thread) and may very well be operating the dam illegally.
But with the legislative influence and votive power of Tacoma and Pierce County, their position is nearly invulnerable. And they know it, therefore they'll do nothing until they're forced.
So, the tensions and incivilities along the Skok will continue to escalate until bloodshed happens, then the US Marshals will be brought in, and the tribe will finally get their day in court.
And the sport fisherman will ultimately lose, again. The fish?? Oh well...everyone say: let WDFW take care of it. After 20 years of studies, they'll get around to doing something, maybe.
Sorta makes you wonder, doesnt it.