The trailer alone is probably worth $300 to $500, if it's in good shape, with no rust, working lights, good tires, etc.

I haven't seen a good fiberglass or aluminum boat in the papers for much less than $2000, and more like $2500 in the state you describe. I'd offer 1750 to 1900, depending on how you feel about that guy.
_________________________
Hm-m-m-m-m