I have fished with all of the above mentioned guides including a few others on the Quinault. Robbin is my choice. I fished with Robbin a week ago just after the rain began. Once again he worked hard all day, dawn til dark. We stay in his rental house which is on the river a short walk to the boat across his front lawn. His new sled is comfortable and the house is too. Be sure to hit JJ's for a great breakfast and a very good sack lunch for the day...Lunch with one sandwich is $6.00 and with two sandwiches it's $7.00...go figure. Still searching for that 40# steelhead which is no doubt coming to the Quinault this winter.