This is a good discussion.

Smalma, I thought McMillan's presentation was thought provoking and an interesting study. The main reason I posted it was to stimulate some discussion. I appreciate fact that you took the time to eloborate on the validity of the statement. Perhaps this information should be feedback to McMillan.

Posting this statement was a attempt to get anglers to think further about the issues. I agree we cannot point the finger at just one issue there are many, right? The reason I posted the statement on the Hatchery Closure thread was to stimulate some perspective on the issue at hand instead of dragging along a boring argument blaming Eymen or praising him. On your last paragraph, I couldn't agree more.

Goose, that was also a interesting point.