I'd go to the Columbia. The fish that go up the Quilluate (spelling??) and the Sol Duc are 100% hatchery I believe and aren't very aggressive. I remember fishing last year for them and seeing them jump everywhere but ended up with one missed strike at the end of the day. We were using wrapped kwikies for them. The other boat in our party did hit one however and it was a beautiful chromer that was almost 20 I'd say. But I've always had better success on the Columbia in my uncles boat.