Brood stock programs have done some good in places. The Wynooche and maybe Satsop come to mind. Other rivers in desperate shape might use them too, like the Nisqually and Puyallup. But why have one on a river with a strong wild stock like the Sol Duc? Then expand it to the Calawah? Could be screwing with some of the the last best wild runs we have. It's a feelgood program for the guides, and I applaud any effort to help fish with good intentions, but wonder how necessary it is.