Ok,
I just went back and reread a bunch of both of your guys threads (Dogfish and Driftboater)
There is no question in my mind that a "duel" is going to be the only way to settle this debate!
Since I am the "master" of duels on this board, I will need to be the ones who set the rules!
Rule 1) the weapons of choice will be "rubbers" (they are the most commonly used weapons on this board). They worked the last time, and nobody got screwed up, so we will use them again!
Rule 2) the "rubbers" must be made from pure "American rubber" (no imported or Iraq rubbers will be allowed)
Rule 3) you both have a choice of who will be your rubber bearers (no griners will be allowed).
Rule 4) your choice of "bearers" will be one these members; 4Salt; Chappy; or H20. If 4Salt defaults, then Cowlitzfisherman will reluctantly be a substitute.
Rule 5) the winner must take all (that includes all unused rubbers that may have been left unused.... or miss used). Duels are always very messy!
Rule 6) the place of the dual will be decided when both sides can clam down
Final rule; lets all calm down and wait a while before we all get to excited!
And this time I do believe that "bearers" and "duel" are spelled correctly!
Cowlitzfisherman
