M101, what's up bud? IMO they are the same. What's the difference between the line sweeping down on a moving fish and a moving fish running into a stationary line. They are both bumping into the line with their mouth and getting hooked. The Blue Creek (or fill in any river w/good hatchery run) guys and the Samish guys are doing the same thing. Before the jig craze it used to be a glob of eggs w/or without weight at the Samish for me. I'm sure lots of them kings were biters, but I'm also sure many were lined. It's the same w/ that jig sitting in the mud. When a king hits your line, it sure feels like it's attacking the [Bleeeeep!] out off your lure. Maybe it is maybe it isn't. But until we can figure out how to interview a salmon/steelhead about to be clubbed whether or not it voluntarily struck the lure/bait then I say let's assume it did.