FF-

Go with the Scotty's, I have used all major brands and like the Scotty DR's the most for ease of use, dependability, durability. Penn's are nice too but too expensive for what they are. I have heard that some of the newer penn's have problems with their gearbox seals.

Keep an eye on eBay, I see alot of DR's go through there with some nice deals to be had on new and used. Also check 3 rivers as they have some deals from time to time.


edit-

You can see in my avatar pic I have a Penn 825 on the right, and you can just barely see the arm of the Scotty behind me on the left. Both Downriggers get me into the fish, but The Penn's days are numbered and will be replaced w/ another Scotty.

I have also heard that the Local Scotty rep is real nice, and if you break a part he ususally has therm on-hand for a quick swap-out. Much better than dealing with a servcie person or sending your DR somewhere if that was required. Contact him through 3 Rivers marine.