That is really a perfect example of over simplification Marsha. There is a lot on the line and a lot of folks are going to have their lives impacted by this ruling in one way or the another. It is much more complicated that you try to make it out to be. If you don't like these discussions then don't waste your time reading them. I've personally found them both enlightening and somewhat enjoyable and I appreciate that Bob has allowed a lot of freedom on his board for the topics and opinions. Theres a lot of people reading these discussions and a lot of good information and ideas have been tossed around how could that possibly be a bad thing, regardless of what side of the issue your on.