Fishon - Thanks for the blackmouth advice, I'll give it a try and make sure I tie a good knot so I get the cutplug when I'm done.

I suspected they were a bit collectable, but I don't see them at garage sales much on the island.

The other vintage lure that stands out to me is the Pearl Wobbler. (Abalone shell w/ red dot, correct?) Looks like it would be fun to troll too.
Any luck fishing these?

Thanks again guys - Charr, Let us know if you land a blackmouth on your cutplug this winter!