Originally posted by Theking:
Are they mistakes or differences of opinion? ... Many say for example that Schwarzkopf is right. Well as much as I like ol stormin he did not have to hang out and rebuild the entire country like this go around in Iraq. So his opinions are completley speculative at best. ... (if) everyone rooled up there sleves and offered the current admin full support it would appear 1000x smoother if not in fact have gone a little smoother.
It's not opinion, it's historical fact of mistakes made. There's only those that won't admit them.
When people like Shinseki, Zinni, Schwarzkopf, et al express opinion, that is based on years and years of military study, experience, and practical anecdotes. Their opinion cannot be dismissed as purely speculative. Compare that to the resume of the current DefSec and his minions who have virtually nill time in uniform.
If indeed we "offered the current admin full support," it would not have had any bearing on the outcome or repercussions of what has happened - other than the public burying its head in the sand and accepting mediocrity from its leaders. The war would not have gone any better, yet the administration would have had an easier time spewing its propaganda.