Not only did her bait not spin, but she's a damn righty and cuts the plugs as a right hander.

As a lefty, I cut the opposite way, and run the hooks the opposite way. Knife in left hand, bait in right with the fish head facing towards the left.

Totally throws me for a loop when I'm handed a right-handed cut herring. I swear I have to sit there and actually stop and think how to rig up a right handed cut plug. Kills me every damn time!

Freakin' righties. Learn to cut a herring *properly*!!!