Didn't want this to get buried under the tiger trout topic and it is a very good topic to discuss. I read everyone's viewpoints and I agree with both sides actually.

My problem with powerbait, and other types of bait is when people grade the fish. By this I mean, they fish with bait... catch an 8" fish... know there are bigger fish then try to release the 8" fish.

Fish caught with bait RARELY live. They may look okay when they swim off, but they aren't. It is very difficult to release fish caught with bait. That is why we have the regulation, "when using bait the first five fish you catch are your limit" (paraphrased). Grading has gotten so bad on some of our waters that I have looked into "No Bait" regs on some of them. But that would take away the opportunity for kids who are not really into the whole fly fishing style or use of lures.

We as an agency need to do more to educate about how to catch and release... however, when you use bait you should be keeping those fish if it is legal to do so. Once you have caught your five trout using bait you are done for the day... period.

The thing I don't like about powerbait is that it leaves a nasty film on top of the water and if a bunch of people are using it the fish stop biting simply because there is so much bait floating around. I have seen this on several lakes on Opening Day.

But, I do not think one user group (bait vs. fly fishers) is better than another. It is our goal (in Reg. 5) to provide opportunities for both groups. If you do use bait, please please be careful about releasing these fish. If you don't intend to eat them or take them home, then use another method (lures etc) if possible. It saves the fish for another day.

That was a great discussion by the way. No problem with getting passionate about how you feel, as long as it's polite!

stace