Hi Big John,
I've read other people's responses and agree with some of what was said, but of the 3 or 4 times I've been to Potholes I've found the fishing to be above average. One person mentioned being willing to switch up tactics or chase different species of fish. Following that tactic has worked well for me.....some days I couldn't touch a bass, but did well on walleye. Other days I'd target walleye then switched over to trout with better success.

I've really only fished Potholes later in the season, but typically the fishing has been good.