Hmmm good question, well is the guy who claims it a nice guy or some jerk? If he is a pretty cool guy, then I would give it back, but if he is a jerk I would tell him, what's mine is mine and what yours is now mine... but if you fish the river alot, you probally don't want a whole lot of enemies hehe... well good luck and keep the lines tight...
_________________________
Whiteman Renegade fan club