I believe Bob has some great ideas that he learned from Alaska. The only problem I see is the one Rich pointed out about guides who practice bonking with new clients everyday. The guides clients would be lucky to catch there fish without a guide. Its the guide who is doing the damage to the fishery not the client who bonks two a year. Bob knows the fellow guides who target the fish in the open waters day after day in the Quilayute and Hoh systems. So do the sportsmen who fish on a regular basis. (Jimmy,Gordon,Rodney,Jeff,1stH20... along with the others). That whole yearly limit on the Hoh (2 fish a year)and Quilayute( 5 fish) was backed by the Forks guide association to the benefit of the guides not the fish. People who spent thousands of dollars for there boats and equipment can keep two fish from there favorite river, while the guide can keep two everyday for the entire season. I would like to see a limit placed on the guides so they can only fish the c&r waters or keep only marked fish while fishing with a guide. Thats my two cents