I don't have the jig experience of Jigman as I'm mostly a drift fisherman, but I've caught several steelhead on painted heads (eyes and no eyes) as well as just plain lead-head jigs (no paint at all). It doesn't seem to matter a whole lot. One thing I think that does matter is the shade of the feathers, maribou, etc., which I change depending on the clarity and level of water that you are fishing. White or light blue is my favorite for low, clear water. I also tip the jig with a shrimp tail, which seems to work well.