Perhaps if the "paying public" was actually aware of the cost for hatchery fish on a per fish basis, things might have been shut down a long time ago. People might "want" to take home a fish, but no one "needs" to take home a fish. There are much more efficient ways to "feed" one's family.

Poachers will poach no matter the season, abundance, or penalties. You don't let criminals set policy, instead you set penalties for the act...and enforce them.

C&R fishing allows more people to enjoy the resource that is left. It never fails to amaze me that most people can only define their wildlife encounter with the death of the animal.