The logic behind that is simple, most rivers that are open for salmon retention are hatchery fish dominated, with depleted wild stocks. Therefor by everyone else's logic we should shut down all fishing and remove all hatchery fish. Let every river rebound on it's own.

I guess personally I'm just tired of hearing the rah rah rah get rid of the hatchery fish on the Elwha [Bleeeeep!], when three or four posts down on the main page a bunch of harvested hatchery fish are being celebrated.