This whole mess of a thread started because someone complained about giving information on this site about someone's certain holes or rivers.If someone want's to let everyone know how they did on a certain river that's their bisness.If you don't want to tell where you caught a fish so be it.I wouldn't post about my own rivers but we shouldn't slam people for the posts they make about where they caught fish.Learning to use your gear properly and reading water is the key to consistently catching fish not what hole or river to go to.If you can't read water and fish effectively it won't matter where you fish.For rookie fishers there are many good books out there you should read that will help you get started and you can learn alot from the posts on here about techniqe.I'm not slamming or calling anyone a rookie I just hate to see threads of this nature.