I have been a huge shimano fan for years but I haven't bought any of the newer ones because I'm not a fan of the thumb bars(my personal hang-up). So I can't say much about the Corsiar. However, I also own several 5000 and 5500's. I compare them to the blue collar worker, they just go to work everyday and get the job done!!! So if you are going to spend 40-70$ I would definately recommend the 5500. Great reel for the begginner or the expert.