I have fished the Quinault for years with various guides but prefer Robbin Rhoades. He is a hard working guide who could teach some lessons in hard work to many non-indian guides. The fishery is healthy and is definitely a catch and keep show. Robbin guides some of this state's most well known catch and release "experts" as well. That river supports a fair number of tribal members and plays host to fishermen from all over with widely diverse opinions. Check out Robbin's website at www.quinaultguideservice.net..... get his side of this story.