Neah Bay hands down and thank you Bubs. My family and I have been going to Neah Bay for our family vacation for many years. I have yet to ever have an incident. It is far my favorite place on the face of the earth. If there is a prettier place I would have a hard time believing it. There is more fish there of every kind. I halibut fish there Canadian and US. Last year the kings were so thick at Umatilla Reef that we didn't fish for much else. If having to small of a boat is a problem, buy a bigger boat. It worked for me. The Makahs are very nice and helpful, I talk to many of them every year. They will let you know where the hogs are being caught by some of their fishermen. Last year the huge kings were being caught at Bluedot-50&60 pounders-but that is a long run. Joey and Wendy Lawrence are dong a great job of running the new big Salmon. Everything everyone said above is true. But if you get seasick, you might not like it. As far as the state stores not being there, I go to fish not to drink.