Quote:
Originally posted by Plunker:

The science says you are wrong. C&R or WSR has never helped a steelhead population avoid the swings encountered by non-C&R regulated populations.

Plunk...Don't know about natural swings , but do know that on Vancouver Island, where C&R has been in effect on wild fish for some time...they actually have lots of wild summer fish left. Sure does not seem to be hurting it there.