PacificNW,

Hatchery surplus is not the yardstick to use if wild salmon represent society's values. The key question is: are there consistent surpluses of naturally spawning coho in all the Grays Harbor tributaries? If so, then arguably, the commercial net fishery is not adversely affecting recreational fishing opportunity, provided there are always season long openings for recreational fishing. If not, society should examine its priorities and adjust fish management accordingly.

I suppose it's an unfortunate aspect of recreational fisheries on non-feeding migratory fish that a large abundance of fish is necessary in order for sport fishing to be productive. Managing for maximum, or even optimal, net harvests, with minimum escapements, is an indication that recreational fishing is an afterthought, at most.

Sincerely,

Salmo g.