Another vote for a wagon. I think my next car will be one of the Suburu Legacy GT wagons... basically a sport wagon. Too bad they stopped making the manual transmission is 2006. I've also looked at Saabs, Volvos, and 5 series BMW wagons. The plus and minus of the Suburu is the 4WD. It is great when you need it. Otherwise it is just bringing the MPG down.

If you REALLY want a sedan, I'd do exactly what 4Salt said and get another Accord. I agree that it will be the best value you can get and will go forever. I have two co-workers that have gotten really good deals on Nissan Altimas. They look like rental cars to me but they are quiet, big, have the trunk, and aren't pathetically underpowered.