Darn, wish CL would cooperate more readily on these types of cases. Maybe the police would issue the Supeona?? I hit the No Contact info button hoping the guy would edit his ad, he must have freaked and cancelled.

At least it gives you an area to focus on; Puyallup. Check the South Hill pawn shops etc. and hopefully it will turn up.
I would also put a wanted ad for the exact same motor in Craigslist to see if the dumb mutha &^%&^*%!! responds.