I think I got lucky...I've got a Pentax Optio W10, old school, and it still takes good pics, and always has, many of which have made their way into fishing mags.

That being said, the reviews on them have been very mixed, as AP said above, but I can't get myself to drop the coin on a new camera since it still works fine, and after all these years is still waterproof as all get out...

Fish on...

Todd