seeing as how Todd was an attorney, the funnest way to handle it might be to identify the owner of the boat and then file a huge civil claim against them. TMaybe get Marsha to get a few other claims, claim huge damages, and let them hire an attorney to fight it. Only cost would be the filing. Most likely they will try to ignore it, which then would leave them open to a default judgement, then you go after the boat.

We had a employee who stole a bunch of money. Sued, got the judgement, and 9 years later she got married and tried to buy a home. We ended up getting back all money in the end.