Doc -
I'm not questioning the Forks Creek data or the potential use of it however the title of this thread -

"Hatchery vs wild ... segregation does NOT work" seems like a pretty strong statement and seems leaves little room to look at individual caes.

It is something like say since Puget Sound steelhead numbers continue to be depressed inspite of wide spread application of Wild Steelhead Release regulations WSR does not work. Clearly this issue are much more complex than thant we need to look them with clear eyes with the best science in mind.

Tight lines
Curt