I looked at the links to the boats (see below). If you're locked in to the Lund or Alumaweld, I'd take the Alumaweld if for not other reason than it has a windshield and you can put canvas on it. Fishing our waters can be cold and wet and you'll want canvas.

http://www.lundboats.com/boats/2013-aluminum/alaskan/1800-alaskan

http://www.alumaweldboats.com/Talon-18.htm

I'd pick the Wooldridge Sport Offshore over either the Lund or the Alumweld. Heavier construction, more deadrise/deeper Vee, bigger fuel tank, etc

http://www.wooldridgeboats.com/catalog/products/sport-offshore