I'm pretty sure the diehard jig fishers will disagree, but a cigarette butt on a leadhead (unpainted) will catch about as many fish as a perfectly tied jig with the best vinyl painted head and purtiest feathers.

Fish on...

Todd

P.S. I have that same opinion about steelhead worms, too...put it in front of a steelhead and they will likely eat it. Or not...but a chipped leadhead or a cheap feather will not be the deciding factor.